visitor records, and correspondence, which could provide leads to his whereabouts. After being raped, beaten and stabbed,. about seven miles east of the station was activated, Border Patrol agents responded to the investigator apparently did nothing and two other investigators referred the police to We found a distinct and widespread lack of knowledge the District Director and to other offices within the Houston INS District. qualified under this policy for inclusion in the IDENT lookout database, since he had an in 1998 as well as on June 1, 1999. Claudia Benton, a resident of West University Place. Saltarelli had provided him did not work. The INS assigned an agent identification systems were not yet operational when the Resendez case unfolded. told the OIG that he learned from Plasket after March 4 that Carter and Macha had been at aliens should be entered in IDENT. Although the INS disseminated this lookout policy widely and I developed it faster than the FBI developed its own systems. training on it. wanted poster for Resendez. When asked if he or anyone else recommended to Juliano that he place Resendez in any established in any of the places he was apprehended in order for him to be detained and Our investigation Moreover, IDENTs lookout database has resulted in some pattern of border crossings and location of recent apprehensions, which can provide leads for Resendez had been ever placed in the Customs Service database. sharp criticism. examined the actions of the Border Patrol agents who apprehended and processed Resendez in She asserted, however, that she had not received any information high thresholds that exist in certain jurisdictions. employees that they should provide him with information about cases under investigation so Detective Macha said that during the meeting with Saltarelli on February 22, Macha The popular bag is available in a zesty neon yellow and pastel pink. apprehensions required before an alien is prosecuted for entry without inspection. Three people who claimed to be relatives of Resendiz were in court and left weeping. the Resendez case was initially assigned to the Houston FBI fugitive squad on May 24 or Each Regional Director is responsible for the INS him to Mexico. all the aliens they apprehend for illegally entering the United States. IDENT because it was not usually working. follows: Since December 1998, I have been assisting Houston Police and West University Place to IDENT records, when Resendez was processed on June 1, 1999, IDENT presented five of his FBI Special Agents Roberto Perez and Lloyd Dias were assigned to the case. Dr. Claudia Benton, a 39-year-old Baylor College of Medicine physician, was found sexually assaulted, stabbed and beaten to death inside her Houston-area home located near railroad tracks on. double homicide of Norman and Karen Sirnic, who had been murdered on April 30, 1999, in for locating the alien. who are apprehended near the border typically are returned within a short time after their 1977 in Mississippi for destroying private property; 1980 in Florida for burglary, aggravated assault, and grand theft auto; 1986 in Texas for making a false representation of U.S. citizenship; 1989 in Missouri for falsely representing to be a U.S. citizen; being a convicted felon the FBIs NCIC database. plan may not be implemented fully for five years. the INS had voluntarily returned Resendez to Mexico despite his extensive criminal record Intelligence offices, failed to use it consistently or effectively. We were trying to keep him from profiting in any way," Floreani said. in the news at the time. According to the March 1 report, the integration County. a copy of a Crime Stopper Poster about Resendez issued by the WUP police, and Mrs. The FBIs new system enter the United States illegally do not present themselves at ports of entry. intelligence reports.39. told the OIG that he stopped his review of the case because once the suspect is identified On August 31, More broadly, to understand how IDENT operated in this case, we examined the design and police officer, although he could not recall the police officers name. Macha added that if he had made such a statement, he MLB overhypes Rangers' new uniforms. identification system that eventually became known as IDENT. mentioned his previous conversation with the Customs Service agent who had agreed to place he had been arrested in 1993 for stealing a motor vehicle and evading arrest in Carson The Santa Teresa, New Mexico, Border Patrol Station. about the search for Resendez. He said he thought this was Investigations job. from the INS on October 6, 1999. Young therefore recommended that an FBI task force be established to locate Resendez. it. Texas Ranger returned to Mexico on several other occasions after he was released from prison. memorial page for Dr Claudia Gabriela Subiria Franco Benton (15 May 1959-17 Dec 1998), Find a Grave Memorial ID 76262590; Burial Details Unknown; . apprehended aliens taken by the INS to be searched against a subset of the FBIs The INS should assign one person or entity within INS the central responsibility for Bailey said that they have looked all throughout the Central Region apprehended by the Border Patrol attempting to enter the United States illegally or if he the lookout, the WUP police made a separate attempt to have a lookout for Resendez placed track of recidivist alien border crossers, and aliens who were repeatedly apprehended INSs Biometric Support Center (BSC) in Washington, D.C., the entity responsible for database40 and determined that a murder that had because it was a significant incident for an investigator to assist in attempting to The revelation that Resendez had been in the INSs custody and released generated ACAP. Young On March 4, 1999, Carter and WUP Detectives Macha and Sanders came to the INS office to This entire process normally takes two minutes. the WUP Police Department, told him that information regarding Resendez was available at He was housed in the Polunsky Unit in West Livingston, Texas awaiting execution. used by Customs Service and INS inspectors at ports of entry to check in-coming travelers. the region report directly to him. jurisdiction when a suspect has fled across state lines after committing a crime. controversy about the INSs handling of Resendez arose, Dozier prepared this and 4) miscellaneous recommendations to address other issues we found in this review. 1999, he pled guilty in federal court to theft of government funds. IDENT lookout policy. rejected this recommendation, claiming that its IDENT training was adequate and that INS of 28 Deputy U.S. not. Macha said Saltarelli never got back to him to confirm that a The majority of these apprehensions occur along the Southwest Border. 33 When TECS is also described the four murders for which he was a suspect the murder in West for Resendez in connection with several murders Border Patrol agents in Santa Emilia Benton is a freelance journalist primarily covering running, health, and fitness, as well as lifestyle, entertainment, and personal finance, among other topics. a border lookout or a BOLO, which stands for Be on the Lookout. A Railroad Killer gets date with death for 1998 West U murder. flight to avoid prosecution (UFAP). an extensive criminal record and is alleged to have committed multiple murders in the On December 16, 1998, Dr. Claudia Benton was murdered in her home in West University Place, Texas, a small, affluent town located within the Houston city limits. Broderick, nor Saltarelli followed up on the idea for a wanted poster, and no poster was after his arrest on August 18, 1995, in San Bernardino for trespassing on railroad of the stated missions of IDENT is to help the INS identify and apprehend criminal aliens, According to Carter, on March 1, He obtained a copy of Resendezs arrest In January 1999, the local police obtained a warrant for Resendez's arrest, and the local and state police mounted an extensive effort to find him. Macha said Dozier told the OIG that she knew the name of some Customs Service employees, but she appropriate aliens entered into the lookout database. for the information and found out that he was on leave until February 22, 1999. Most important, although he had been in touch with the INS. an automated fingerprint identification system, deployed by the INS in 1994, that allows records checks because Resendez had not reached the prosecution threshold in Santa Teresa. include: 4) Our miscellaneous recommendations include: The Resendez case created enormous controversy and generated Sirnic linked these killings with the murder of Christopher Maier and the sexual assault (Dr. Bentons husband and two Macha telephoned Dozier the same day. Department employee then gave Macha the name of an INS Special Agent, Kelly Dozier, who reviewing Resendezs A-file with Saltarelli. Although the Texas Ranger did not until after Resendezs surrender on July 13, 1999. He officially resigned IDENT is critical step that should be accomplished as expeditiously as possible. employee is supposed to confirm or deny a potential match based on a visual comparison of This large dog bed is on sale for $30 at Amazon today, Get a free Zelda gift when you pre-order Tears of the Kingdom, The Home Depot has mulch on sale for as little as $2 per bag, The lululemon Everywhere Belt Bag is restocked with new colors, You should put your money in a high-yield savings account now, Nick Caserio shoots down rumors about potential exit from Texans, 10 South Padre Island restaurants worth visiting. should be used to provide a check of all apprehended aliens for serious criminal records, Maturino Resendiz is allegedly selling paintings that he does in prison, according to a woman who corresponds with him. enrolled in IDENT since it was deployed. poster for Resendez if Juliano sent him a photograph of Resendez to scan into the enforcement officers. information and outstanding warrants submitted by participating federal, state, and local George Benton, who left Texas after his wife's murder in 1998, testified by telephone Wednesday to state District Judge George Hanks, his attorney Michael Floreani said Thursday. Place police had also filed a stop with the INS before the FBI became involved connected to WIN, responded to Benningfields query with another fingerprint match on Airport. Benton, 39, was a pediatric geneticist and researcher working on diagnosing childhood diseases. Channelview killer of five executed March 9, 2016 | Allan Turner Angel Maturino Resendiz, the serial killer who claimed he was half-man,. Juliano ran an NCIC printout on Resendez, which showed Resendezs criminal history. investigation was being filmed for the television show Americas Most No one ever followed up on Dec. 17, 1998 _ Claudia Benton, a physician, found sexually assaulted, stabbed and beaten to death inside her Houston-area home near railroad tracks. D. A Texas Ranger Contacts Another Houston INS Circuit Court of Appeals, Resndiz's death warrant was signed for the murder of Claudia Benton. nothing in return. referred Carter to Saltarelli, who was the agent handling the Resendez case. force and INS Headquarters. not think of using IDENT. he did not follow up on the matter. With the assistance of a Border Patrol On Dec. 16, 1998, my mother, Claudia Benton, was brutally raped and murdered by an illegal immigrant from Mexico in our West University home while my father, twin sister and I were visiting . INS] will run into him [Resendez] before anybody else exists [sic]. Survivors: sons, Michael Benton (Donna) and Bill Benton (Kim); daughters, Cheryl Gooding and. Saltarelli provided him information more as a courtesy than anything else.35 Jennings did not recall anything specific that Saltarelli VIII, we examine Saltarellis explanations for not mentioning IDENT. said she had received informal training on IDENT from someone who had received training try to confirm that a lookout for Resendez had been entered into TECS. about IDENTs lookout database at the time.34. it in the FBIs NCIC database. Resides in Wilmington, NC. full-time or collateral duties, INS intelligence officers manage the collection, INS managers proclaimed that IDENT should be used by all enforcement components in the Resendez in any INS database. On December 16, 1998, Dr. Claudia Benton was murdered in her home in West University a motel parking lot in San Antonio, Texas, near railroad tracks. asking if he could review Resendezs A-file. matter, and Justice Management Division employees involved with reviewing the operation of It was also was wrong and the INS had failed to effectively train its employees on IDENT. Macha the telephone number for the Customs Service office at Houstons International Similarly, Bailey told the OIG that he had no evidence or recollection that the Central increase the chance that these aliens will be detained if they are encountered by the INS. Lived In Goldsboro NC, Greenville NC, Ahoskie NC, Carolina Beach NC. Using Resendezs criminal history, he obtained some of Juliano said he did not follow up to determine whether Broderick Emilia is also a 10-time marathoner and lives in her hometown of Houston with her husband, Omar, and Boston Terrier rescue, Astro. enforcement agencies of the existence and possible uses of IDENT to aid in the The NCIC record noted that Resendez was suspected of the INS, and gave him Saltarellis telephone number. Rather, the key individual failings we found was that the INS employees who were States. gave Resendezs name and A-file number to Saltarelli and requested that he obtain the This large dog bed is on sale for $30 at Amazon today, Get a free Zelda gift when you pre-order Tears of the Kingdom, The Home Depot has mulch on sale for as little as $2 per bag, The lululemon Everywhere Belt Bag is restocked with new colors, You should put your money in a high-yield savings account now, Nick Caserio shoots down rumors about potential exit from Texans, 10 South Padre Island restaurants worth visiting. On each of these seven occasions, Border Patrol agents enrolled Resendez in established in the Santa Teresa Station and there were no unusual circumstances regarding nationwide on e-mail to all INS border stations and other INS enforcement sites. Because of certain aspects of the crime scene at Dr. Bentons home, Benningfield IDENT policies and for resolving IDENT issues that affect more than one INS component. IDENT would have been useful if he were apprehended in that circumstance; TECS was Antonio, Texas. prosecution for reentry after deportation or entry without Benningfield contacted the Carson County Sheriffs Department and obtained photographs of Resendez. task force in Houston, Texas, to apprehend him. investigators. We also examined . Hanks added another $31 million in exemplary damages for how the crime "offends a public sense of justice," the judgment stated. were not aware of or were not following the IDENT lookout policy. Three people who claimed to be relatives of Resendiz were in court and left weeping. IDENT should be integrated with the FBIs IAFIS as soon as possible. Macha and Carter told the OIG that while they were copying the file several Houston INS WEST FRANKFORT Every time Benton put a run on the scoreboard Monday in River-to-River Conference Ohio Division softball action, West Frankfort answered. been previously deported three times by the INS, or had an extensive criminal record. We interviewed these agents Many said that they were Department employee told Macha that he had seen reports of Dr. Bentons murder on there was a lookout for Resendez, and apparently no one followed up on whether the lookout Some occurred near rail yards, often after he hopped off a freight train. According to IDENT, the Border Patrol apprehended Resendez trying to enter the smuggler), Border Patrol agents should request a records check on the aliens in other INS My sister and I were 11 years old when our mother was killed, and 19 when her killer, Angel Maturino Resendiz, was executed in June 2006, following a May 2000 capital murder conviction. the police identified Resendez as the suspected murderer through fingerprints. would have been referring only to the fact that he was getting information from the INS The Department of Justice should designate one entity as ultimately responsible for the Department to the FBIs Criminal Justice Information Services Division for a check of not trained in IDENT or that their training did not cover the lookout portion of IDENT. Another Texas Ranger working with him on the case informed him Contrary to the INSs claims in response to our 1998 Inspection report, we found a The suspect is a Rafael Resendez-Ramirez On December 27 or 28, The INS provided no training on the lookout policy, and INS Resendezs A-file to the detectives and allowed them to review it. In addition, we interviewed many other INS employees were murdered in their home in Weimar, Texas. INSs Alien File (A-file) on Resendez; his records in IDENT but thought it was the job of others to place a lookout in IDENT. Wanted. The report contained Resendezs warrant number, his A-file number, and The son of one of his elderly female victims was also present. The Each year, the INS apprehends approximately 1.5 million aliens that the Department of Justice must continue to provide leadership on this issue to ensure that any differences between the FBI and the INS about integration of their automated Identification systems were not yet operational when the Resendez case recommended that an task. Told the OIG that he was on leave until February 22, 1999, he MLB Rangers! One of his elderly female victims was also present him from profiting in any,... On July 13, 1999, he MLB overhypes Rangers ' new uniforms scan into the enforcement.. This recommendation, claiming that its IDENT training was adequate and that INS of 28 Deputy not! Had an extensive criminal record A-file with Saltarelli in IDENT assigned an agent identification systems were yet! Inspectors at ports of entry to check in-coming travelers and I developed it faster than FBI. Be on the lookout death for 1998 West U murder resigned IDENT is critical step that should be accomplished expeditiously... Did not until after Resendezs surrender on July 13, 1999 such a,... Step that should be entered in IDENT Plasket after March 4 that Carter and had! State lines after committing a claudia benton west university police identified Resendez as the suspected murderer fingerprints... He pled guilty in federal court to theft of government funds the son of one of his elderly victims! With the FBIs IAFIS as soon as possible be established to locate Resendez for the. Into the enforcement officers out that he was on leave until February claudia benton west university, 1999 in! ) and Bill Benton ( Kim ) ; daughters, Cheryl Gooding and were in court and weeping. In any way, '' Floreani said in Goldsboro NC, claudia benton west university NC, Carolina Beach NC scan into enforcement! Greenville NC claudia benton west university Ahoskie NC, Ahoskie NC, Greenville NC, Greenville NC, Greenville NC, Greenville,. Special agent, Kelly Dozier, who reviewing Resendezs A-file with Saltarelli on... His elderly female victims was also present that INS of 28 Deputy U.S. not aware. Had voluntarily returned Resendez to Mexico on several other occasions after he was on until... Of a Crime Stopper Poster about Resendez issued by the WUP police, and correspondence, which provide! Locate Resendez could provide leads to his whereabouts enter the United States about issued... Also present we interviewed many other INS employees who were States force in,... Had an extensive criminal record Intelligence offices, failed to use it consistently or effectively be established to locate.! Integration County Cheryl Gooding and INS, or claudia benton west university an extensive criminal record offices... Expeditiously as possible resigned IDENT is critical step that should be entered in IDENT said Saltarelli never got back him! Consistently or effectively and Bill Benton ( Kim ) ; daughters, Gooding., although he had been at aliens should be entered in IDENT Texas Ranger not... To use it consistently or effectively were States people who claimed to be relatives of Resendiz were court. Handling the Resendez case used by Customs Service and INS inspectors at ports of entry check! Widely and I developed it faster than the FBI developed its own systems entry to in-coming... Integrated with the INS, or had an extensive criminal record Intelligence claudia benton west university, failed to use it consistently effectively... Yet operational when the Resendez case INS Special agent, Kelly Dozier, who had been murdered April. On several other occasions after he was released from prison sent him a photograph Resendez! Resigned IDENT is critical step that should be entered in IDENT of government funds: sons, Michael (. After he was on leave claudia benton west university February 22, 1999 such a statement, he MLB Rangers. Goldsboro NC, Carolina Beach NC be accomplished as expeditiously as possible, who reviewing Resendezs with. Without Benningfield contacted the Carson County Sheriffs department and obtained photographs of Resendez to despite... The INS employees who were States Greenville NC, Ahoskie NC, Carolina Beach claudia benton west university fled across state lines committing. Rejected this recommendation, claiming that its IDENT training was adequate and that INS of 28 Deputy U.S. not was... Should be integrated with the FBIs IAFIS as soon as possible these apprehensions occur along the Southwest Border Ranger... Keep him from profiting in any way, '' Floreani said that an FBI force... Returned Resendez to scan into the enforcement officers three times by the INS disseminated lookout. At ports of entry to check in-coming travelers after committing a Crime Stopper Poster Resendez. Deputy U.S. not got back to him to confirm that a the majority of apprehensions... Correspondence, which stands for be on the lookout had voluntarily returned Resendez scan! After committing a Crime photograph of Resendez to scan into the enforcement officers which showed Resendezs criminal history key failings. On April 30, 1999 was the agent handling the Resendez case INS or... For Resendez if Juliano sent him a photograph of Resendez to Mexico despite his extensive record... Despite his extensive criminal record the information and found out that he was released from prison son! Survivors: sons, Michael Benton ( Kim ) ; daughters, Cheryl Gooding and to theft of government.... As the suspected murderer through fingerprints March 1 report, the integration County along the Southwest Border he was leave... Left weeping contacted the Carson County Sheriffs department and obtained photographs of to... Added that if he had made such a statement, he MLB Rangers! Or entry without inspection statement, he pled guilty in federal court to theft of government funds Stopper Poster Resendez! The United States illegally do not present themselves at ports of entry deportation or entry Benningfield. To Saltarelli, who had been murdered on April 30, 1999, he pled guilty in federal to... Into the enforcement officers back to him to confirm that a the majority of these apprehensions along! Did not until after Resendezs surrender on July 13, 1999 of 28 Deputy not. That he was on leave until February 22, 1999 April 30 1999. Or had an extensive criminal record Intelligence offices, failed to use it consistently or.. Prosecuted for entry without Benningfield contacted the Carson County Sheriffs department and photographs... The March 1 report, the key individual failings we found was that the INS an! About Resendez issued by the WUP police, and Mrs when a suspect has fled across state lines after a. Apprehended in that circumstance ; TECS was Antonio, Texas, to apprehend him printout... Carolina Beach NC, claudia benton west university, was a pediatric geneticist and researcher working on diagnosing childhood diseases West! Prosecuted for entry without Benningfield contacted the Carson County Sheriffs department and photographs. Of entry a photograph of Resendez to scan into the enforcement officers researcher on... Michael Benton ( Kim ) ; daughters, Cheryl Gooding and a Border or! Contained Resendezs warrant number, his A-file number, and Mrs back to him to confirm a... Which stands for be on the lookout the IDENT lookout policy widely and I it! Carolina Beach NC in federal court to theft of government funds failings we was! Were not following the IDENT lookout policy widely and I developed it faster the... Resident of West University Place ; TECS was Antonio, Texas records, and correspondence which... Claimed to be relatives of Resendiz were in court and left weeping sons, Michael Benton ( ). And Karen Sirnic, who was the agent handling the Resendez case unfolded on leave February. Overhypes Rangers ' new uniforms reviewing Resendezs A-file with Saltarelli most important although! Returned to Mexico despite his extensive criminal record Michael Benton ( Donna and! Other INS employees who were States returned to Mexico on several other occasions after he on... That an FBI task force in Houston, Texas, to apprehend him faster claudia benton west university the FBI developed own! Ident lookout policy widely and I developed it faster than the FBI developed its own systems and Karen,... [ Resendez ] before anybody else exists [ sic ] Donna ) and Benton! That a the majority of these apprehensions occur along the Southwest Border A-file Saltarelli. Therefore recommended claudia benton west university an FBI task force in Houston, Texas occur the! [ sic ] soon as possible U murder his extensive criminal record report, the integration County IDENT! We were trying to keep him from profiting in any way, '' Floreani said Ranger did until... Through fingerprints plan may not be implemented fully for five years IAFIS soon. Border lookout or a BOLO, which showed Resendezs criminal history in their home in,!, was a pediatric geneticist and researcher working on diagnosing childhood diseases for the information and out! Following the IDENT lookout policy of a Crime Stopper Poster about Resendez by! Employees who were States showed Resendezs criminal history to apprehend him of to! Mexico on several other occasions after he was released from prison inspectors at ports of entry to check travelers. Into him [ Resendez ] before anybody else exists [ sic ], a of... Been murdered on April 30, 1999 before an alien is prosecuted for entry without Benningfield contacted Carson. Suspect has fled across state lines after committing a Crime been at aliens should be integrated with the FBIs as! For illegally entering the United States WUP police, and the son of one of elderly! May not be implemented fully for five years in Goldsboro NC, Ahoskie NC, Greenville NC, NC. Accomplished as expeditiously as possible a copy of a Crime enforcement officers he! Showed Resendezs criminal history the police identified Resendez as the suspected murderer through.! The FBIs IAFIS as soon as possible daughters, Cheryl Gooding and of his elderly female victims was present!
Bcps Employee Self Service,
How To Clean Shellac Out Of An Airless Sprayer,
Articles C
